From Promise to Practice: Advancing Bacterial Biomonitoring of Salmon Aquaculture
- The expansion of salmon aquaculture has increased the need for reliable and efficient approaches to assess its environmental impacts. Routine compliance monitoring of salmon farms has traditionally relied on morphology-based assessment of benthic macrofaunal communities, which requires considerable taxonomic expertise, time, and financial resources. Advances in environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding have demonstrated that sediment bacterial communities respond rapidly and consistently to aquaculture-derived organic enrichment, and molecular approaches are beginning to be incorporated into environmental monitoring frameworks. However, their application in routine regulatory assessment remains comparatively limited. Broader implementation requires confidence that bacterial indicators are analytically robust, remain reliable despite natural ecological variability, are reproducible across analytical approaches and datasets, and can ultimately be translated into practical monitoring tools. The overarching aim of this thesis was therefore to evaluate whether sediment bacterial communities can provide reliable measures of benthic ecological condition under the methodological and environmental variability encountered in salmon aquaculture monitoring, and whether robust bacterial indicators can ultimately be translated into practical quantitative tools. To address this aim, bacterial community responses were examined across methodological treatments, temporal and environmental gradients, complementary indicator-selection approaches, and independent datasets.
Methodological robustness was evaluated by comparing PCR amplification protocols and quantifying sampling-related variability relative to conventional macrofaunal monitoring. Temporal dynamics were investigated across two salmon production cycles to determine the relative influence of aquaculture impact and natural seasonal variability on bacterial community structure. Reproducible bacterial indicators were subsequently identified using three complementary analytical approaches and compared across two independent Scottish aquaculture datasets. Finally, selected indicators were developed into targeted digital PCR (dPCR) assays and quantified across samples representing different levels of benthic ecological quality.
The findings demonstrated that methodological standardization is a prerequisite for robust bacterial biomonitoring. Although alternative PCR amplification protocols produced substantial differences in bacterial diversity estimates, they yielded highly consistent ecological patterns across the organic enrichment gradient. Likewise, sampling-related variability in bacterial eDNA was comparable to that observed for conventional macrofaunal monitoring, indicating that the molecular approach did not introduce greater background variability than the established monitoring method. This consistency extended beyond methodological variation to temporal ecological dynamics. Across two salmon production cycles, organic enrichment remained the dominant driver of bacterial community structure (59%), whereas temperature variations explained a considerably smaller proportion of community change (1%). Bacterial communities also reflected changes associated with farm management, particularly at intermediate impact levels.
Importantly, the ecological signal was reproducible at the level of individual indicators. The three indicator-selection approaches converged on highly similar sets of enrichment-responsive taxa within each dataset, and several indicators were recovered across both independent datasets. Selected indicators were successfully quantified using dPCR, and their absolute abundances followed the expected ecological quality gradients across independent salmon farm samples. These results demonstrate that sequencing-derived bacterial indicators can be converted into quantitative molecular targets.
Overall, this thesis advances bacterial biomonitoring beyond the demonstration of ecological potential towards the requirements of practical application. The findings show that bacterial responses to aquaculture-derived organic enrichment remain interpretable despite important sources of methodological and natural variability, that reproducible indicators can be identified across complementary analytical approaches and independent datasets, and that these indicators can be translated from sequencing data into quantitative molecular targets. Importantly, the contribution of this work lies not in proposing bacterial metabarcoding as a replacement for established benthic assessment, but in strengthening the scientific basis for its integration into routine environmental monitoring. By connecting methodological evaluation, ecological validation, reproducible indicator discovery, and targeted quantification within a single framework, this thesis helps bridge a gap that has persisted between microbial ecology and its practical application in environmental assessment. It therefore contributes both to the development of bacterial bioindicators as reliable indicators of benthic ecological condition and to building the scientific foundation and confidence required to advance molecular biomonitoring “from promise to practice” in salmon aquaculture.